Critical Reasoning
试题详情
题目：
The art jury will select either Fillmore’s or Clivestone’s sculptures, but not both, for the midwest art show to be held next spring. If Fillmore’s sculptures are chosen, then the show will contain bronze works. If Clivestone’s sculptures are selected, the show will contain sculptures made from stainless steel.
Assuming the statements in the passage are true, which one of the following statements must also be true?
Assuming the statements in the passage are true, which one of the following statements must also be true?
选项:
A、A. The art show might contain no bronze or stainless steel sculptures.
B、B. If the art show contains bronze sculptures, then it is certain that Fillmore's sculptures were chosen for the show.
C、C. The art show will certainly contain either bronze or stainless steel sculptures, and the art show will most certainly not contain both types of sculptures.
D、D. If the art show contains stainless steel sculptures, it is possible, but not certain, that Clivestone's sculptures were selected by the jury for the show.
E、E. If the art show contains neither bronze nor stainless steel sculptures, it is certain that neither Fillmore's nor Clivestone's sculptures were selected for the show.
答案:
D
提问：
听了英老师的讲解说的是这种算归纳题，不能跟原文反着来。E就是反着来所以杀了。但我做题时候觉得E说的没有错啊，我做题时真没体会出来是要我归纳，我只是单纯根据已知，肯定能推出什么 去做的。请老师指点，谢谢
评分:
0
浏览:
1882
提问：
我选了E，请问老师原文指出如果有Fillmore，则会出现bronze，如果有Clivestone，则会出现stainless steel的作品。那么选项指出，如果展品没有铜或不锈钢的雕塑，则肯定不会有F和C的作品。这个为什么不选呢，我看很多同学都有疑惑，但并未找到讲解录音。谢谢！
评分:
0
浏览:
1880
