Critical Reasoning
试题详情
题目：
Music critic: Fewer and fewer musicians are studying classical music, decreasing the likelihood that those with real aptitude for such music will be performing it. Audiences who hear these performances will not appreciate classical music's greatness and will thus decamp to other genres. So to maintain classical music's current meager popularity, we must encourage more young musicians to enter the field.
Which of the following, if true, most weakens the music critic's reasoning?
选项:
A、
A. Musicians who choose to study classical music do so because they believe they have an aptitude for the music.
B、
B. Classical music's current meager popularity is attributable to the profusion of other genres of music available to listeners.
C、
C. Most people who appreciate classical music come to do so through old recordings rather than live performances.
D、
D. It is possible to enjoy the music in a particular genre even when it is performed by musicians who are not ideally suited for that genre.
E、
E. The continued popularity of a given genre of music depends in part on the audiences being able to understand why that genre attained its original popularity.
答案:
C
提问：
我感觉削弱reasoning的话，一般都是削弱逻辑链中间部分？我提炼的逻辑链：study的人少perform的人就少--观众听到的好的音乐就少--人气降低。然后削弱中间部分。对吗？而且一开始我还把这个理解成目标-计划类型的题了，想削弱目标或者计划，选了B。是因为这题目标不重要吗？
评分:
1
浏览:
1834
提问：
想问问唐塘老师，这题我选的b，我想的是最后一句说的是为了提高popularity，我们必须让更多人去进入这个领域，然后我看b直接说了popularity 要归因于什么，我觉得跟原文直接相关，然后c讲的是人，我不明白，难道最后一句话要总结出：popularity和人之间才能做对嘛
评分:
0
浏览:
2270
提问：
逻辑：越来越少人学古典乐-有能力弹古典乐的人少-观众就不会欣赏古典乐
为了保持古典乐的流行性-鼓励更多年轻人加入这个领域
选了D，即便一种音乐被不适合的音乐家演奏，观众还是有可能欣赏的，感觉驳斥了reason呀。
是不是因为a particular genre是张冠李戴或者一个特别的并不能削弱，还是not ideally suited跟aptitude没有必然联系？
C 感觉不知道怎么和原文扯上关系的
评分:
0
浏览:
2642
