还没有登录哦!

[Critical Reasoning]

试题详情

题目:

Driving the steep road to the mountaintop Inca ruins of Machu Picchu is potentially dangerous and hiking there is difficult.  Now the Peruvian government is installing a cable car that will make access much easier, and hence result in a large increase in tourism.  However, since the presence of large numbers of tourists tends to accelerate the deterioration of a site, installation of the cable car is certain to result in harm to the ruins.
 
Which of the following, if true, most seriously calls into question the argument?

选项:

A、The daily number of tourists that are expected to take the cable car to Machu Piccu is smaller than the original resident population of Incas.
B、The construction of the cable car terminal at Machu Picchu will require the use of potentially damaging heavy machinery at the site.
C、Machu Picchu is already one of the most popular tourist sites in Peru.
D、Natural weathering will continue to be a more significant cause of the deterioration of Machu Picchu than tourist traffic.
E、The cable car will replace the tour buses whose large wheels and corrosive exhaust at present do significant damage to the site.

答案:

E

提问:

请郭老师讲解 我选了A 全文说人多造成 A说每天人没那么多 这个选项错误 是因为攻击的原文的fact 但fact是不能反驳的吗?

解答:

点赞0
阅读2106
解答: 郭培月

提问:

老师,我理解的原文的逻辑是:车多,导致游客多,导致污染多。我理解的E选项是,车c比车b对环境好。但是车的影响没反驳到原文游客多导致环境差的这个逻辑:车b也可以带来很多游客,也可以有很多污染。所以我感觉逻辑不严谨,选了A,我知道A也是有逻辑漏洞的,但是我觉得A与“游客多导致污染多”的逻辑关联度更高。我这个做题方法感觉不符合gmat的做法,到底该如何纠正呢。

解答:

点赞0
阅读404
解答: 张慧雯老师

提问:

求问陆旭老师这题的C为什么不对呀?我选对了E,但是我在犹豫C,因为我觉得逻辑链是:因为用了cable car——导致游客增加——最终导致deterioration加剧。那C说游客本来就多,所以有没有这个car影响不大。我也知道逻辑链本身是不完整的,但是我觉得E也不完整,因为E里面只说了tour bus会造成significant damage,但并没有说这个damage到底是高于cable car还是低于cable car。这与C异曲同工啊,都没有明确的程度来区分cable car造成ruin的强弱。所以有些迷惑。。。。。

解答:

点赞0
阅读2048
解答: 英吉老师

提问:

请郭老师讲解 我选了A 全文说人多造成 A说每天人没那么多 这个选项错误 是因为攻击的原文的fact 但fact是不能反驳的吗?

解答:

点赞0
阅读2107
解答: 郭培月老师

提问:

请老师帮助比DE, 原文说cable car对那个地方造成损害,削弱。那么我想就是找其他原因。 D 天气原因 E cable car 取代tour bus ,tour bus 轱辘大对地方损害大。 然后我就想,这两个选项都提到了其他原因进行了削弱,然后我就蒙了

解答:

点赞0
阅读2021
解答: sysadmin老师

提问:

这一题没有录音答疑 我错选了D

解答:

点赞0
阅读2058
解答: sysadmin老师

问个问题

点我领取
免费专项课程
在线咨询